diff --git a/proposals/4204-takedown-recommendation.md b/proposals/4204-takedown-recommendation.md index 546062718ba..eefc79ec4de 100644 --- a/proposals/4204-takedown-recommendation.md +++ b/proposals/4204-takedown-recommendation.md @@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ and they are not a pirate at all. Additionally, if `@yarrgh:example.com` is known to been smuggling contraband via matrix events or media, then there is no mechanism -to mark this content as plunder that should be ceased. +to mark this content as plunder that should be seized. A compounding issue is Moderation bots currently use the `reason` of the ban to determine whether to redact a user's events or not. Which @@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ expected to be consumed by typical moderation tooling or clients. This is to set expectations for policy list curators for how the recommendation should behave and the severity of the consequences. We also provide guidance to allow tool implementers to understand the -context of the recommendations use. Moderation tools or clients are +context of the recommendation's use. Moderation tools or clients are free to interpret the recommendation differently, for example if they are aware of a conflicting policy or they are configured to implement harsher or more liberal consequences for the recommendation. @@ -106,7 +106,7 @@ If the entity of the rule is a server: quarantined or removed. -[^bluesky] This is inspired by work going into bluesky +[^bluesky]: This is inspired by work going into bluesky https://docs.bsky.app/blog/2024-protocol-roadmap#protocol-stability-milestone ## Potential issues @@ -117,6 +117,7 @@ https://docs.bsky.app/blog/2024-protocol-roadmap#protocol-stability-milestone most common use case for the recommendation will be to replace the use of `m.ban` with the reason `spam` targeting a user, which in Mjolnir causes the target user to be banned from protected rooms and + their messages to be redacted. + Because the `reason` is no longer present, a higher degree of trust is required when applying some consequences to these policies. An